huda wrote:
In order to combat Carville’s rampant homeless problem, Mayor Bloomfield recently proposed a ban on sleeping outdoors in the city’s many parks. He claims that such a measure will force the homeless to either leave Carville or to find means other than sleeping in public parks.
Which of the following, if true, suggests that Mayor Bloomfield’s plan will be successful?
A. Until the ban, the city’s many homeless shelters were at less than fifty percent occupancy.
B. Many homeless tend to congregate underneath Carville’s numerous overpasses.
C. Adjacent cities have even tougher measures on the homeless sleeping outdoors.
D. The percent of Carville’s population that has been homeless has been slowly decreasing in the last five years.
E. Mayor Jonesmith, Mayor Bloomfield’s predecessor, had been far more tolerant towards the city’s homeless population.
We need an answer that helps to curb the homeless population if the new plan goes into effect. A does it best as then the homeless would be forced to find a new place, and given the occupancy of homeless shelters is less than fifty percent, this plan seems to work perfectly.
C would weaken the argument.
B, D and E are irrelevant arguments.