aadityayadav12 wrote:
Carcass wrote:
Official Explanation
2. The author of the passage would agree with each of the following EXCEPT:
Difficulty Level: Hard
Explanation
The first line of the passage clearly states that pleasure and enjoyment are the same but that these two terms are not the same as ‘happiness’. Also, nowhere does the passage suggest that pleasure and happiness are linked. Hence, the author will not agree with (A) which is the correct answer.
(B) The passage describes several types of pleasure such as sensual, emotional, imaginative, etc.
(C) The opening line of the passage states that enjoyment and pleasure are the same.
(D) The line ‘It may be unmixed and undisturbed, in which case, however short of duration or coarse in quality, it may in strictness be called happiness’ clearly implies that this is true.
(E) This is the main purpose of the passage.
Answer: A
in the answer choices it is written it may in strictness CANNOT be called happiness
so i think real answer is D
Probably you are correct
- A. Pleasure always leads to happiness: The text does not make this claim. It suggests that if pleasure/enjoyment is pure (unmixed), it is (or can be called) happiness, but it does not argue that all pleasure leads to happiness, especially since the text acknowledges that pleasure can be "troubled and alloyed."
- B. Pleasure can be of different types: The author explicitly states: "Enjoyment, it must be observed, is of various kinds... It may be sensual, or emotional, or imaginative, or intellectual, or moral." (The author would agree).
- C. Enjoyment is no different from pleasure: The text explicitly states: "...which two words will here be treated as synonymous." (The author would agree).
- D. Unmixed enjoyment cannot strictly be called enjoyment:
This contradicts the text. The author states: "It may be unmixed and undisturbed, in which case... it may in strictness be called happiness." By definition, if it is enjoyment, it is enjoyment; the author actually argues that unmixed enjoyment qualifies for the title of happiness.
- E. The sole purpose of life is the quest for happiness: The text states: "the sole object of existence [is] enjoyment or pleasure... happiness, also... being occasionally substituted for them." Given the synonymy, the author would agree with this.