I agree totally with soumya regarding the example just poste by the student.
In this latter scenario you can not say which SD is higher unless you perform calculation
However, regarding the main topic, conceptually you can achive the solution without any calculation.
We do have set A 10,20,30
Set B 10,20,20,20,20,20,30
Now if you consider this simple concept
Quote:
If every element in the data set is equal, they all equal the mean, each deviation from the mean is zero, and the standard deviation is zero. This is the lowest possible standard deviation for any set to have.
From this you can infer that the SD of the first set is a little bit higher of the second one because it has LESS 20' in there. Considering that in both sets 10 and 30 are equal, because just present the gist of the problem boils down to the presence of the 20'. In the second set we have MORE 20'. As such, the SD is more "diluted", thinner.
The first set has a SD higher. For this reason A is the answer.
Hope this helps