Re: A recent survey of wine-writing over the past decade turns up a striki
[#permalink]
09 Aug 2026, 23:09
1. The Logical Skeleton
The Trend: The sentence describes a recent shift in wine-writing over the past decade. Critics are now focusing heavily on their own personal perspectives-specifically "centering their own palates, memories, and moods above all else."
Blank (i): We need a word that captures this extreme self-centeredness or self-absorption in writing.
The Contrast ("this despite the fact that..."): The second half introduces a sharp contrast between this modern self-centered trend and the traditional ideal of criticism.
Blank (ii): Historically, "generations of critics" believed in the opposite approach-judging the wine objectively without personal bias or emotional influence. We need a word that means objectivity, impartiality, or emotional detachment.
2. Why the Correct Options Work
F. solipsism (noun): The philosophical idea that only one's own mind is sure to exist, or broadly, extreme self-absorption/egocentricity. Centering only one's internal "memories and moods" above the objective object being reviewed (the vintage) is an act of literary solipsism.
A. dispassion (noun): Freedom from passion, bias, or emotion; objective impartiality. This stands as the direct traditional virtue that opposes subjective, mood-driven reviewing.
3. Why the Distractors Fail
Blank (i):
B. partisanship (noun): Prejudice or bias in favor of a particular cause, political party, or faction. While modern reviews are biased, the bias described is specifically self-centeredness, not devotion to a political or factional party.
C. lucidity (noun): Clarity or easy comprehensibility. Personal anecdotes and moods do not inherently make writing clearer or more lucid.
Blank (ii):
D. incivility (noun): Rudeness or impolite behavior. The text contrasts self-centeredness with traditional professional standards, not with politeness.
E. conformity (noun): Compliance with standards, rules, or laws; behavior in accordance with socially accepted conventions. While critics adhered to shared standards, the core virtue opposed to "centering one's own mood" is objective judgment (dispassion), not mere blind conformity.