Question 3
Now let's look at question #3:
Quote:
Which of the following statements best characterizes the relationship between traditional social science models of class and Ryan's model, as described in the passage?
Here is what the passage says about "traditional social science models of class":
Quote:
Traditional social science models of class groups in the United States are based on economic status and assume that women's economic status derives from association with men, typically fathers or husbands, and that women therefore have more compelling common interest with men of their own economic class than with women outside it.
The conclusion reached by social scientists applying "traditional models of class" is that "women... have more compelling common interest with men of their own economic class than with women outside it."
The reason behind this conclusion is that "women's economic status derives from association with men, typically fathers or husbands."
Here is what the passage says about Mary Ryan's findings:
Quote:
Social historian Mary Ryan, for example, has argued that in early-nineteenth-century America the identical legal status of working-class and middle-class free women outweighed the differences between women of these two classes: married women, regardless of their family's wealth, did essentially the same unpaid domestic work, and none could own property or vote.
Ryan's conclusion is that "the identical legal status of working-class and middle-class free women outweighed the differences between women of these two classes."
The main contrast between these two viewpoints is as follows:
- Traditional models: show that economic status is more important than gender when examining divisions in society
- Mary Ryan: believes that gender is more important than economic status when examining divisions in society
Now look at (B):
Quote:
(B) The traditional social science model of class differs from Ryan's in its assumption that women are financially dependent on men.
The traditional models described in the passage do make the assumption that "women's economic status derives from association with men." But, is this a
difference between the traditional models and Ryan's argument?
Ryan does not specifically
disagree with the notion that women are financially dependent on men. She just believes that gender is a more important factor than economic status when examining class in society.
Because the two models do not differ on this point, (B) is not the correct answer.
I hope that helps!