Question 2
gmatimothy wrote:
For Q2, I knew the primary purpose of the passage is to highlight genes and their control but didn't pick (A) because the 1st paragraph didn't mention anything about genes. My rule of thumb for primary purpose questions was to pick an answer that is applicable to every single paragraph of the passage. Any insights?
A good first step is to identify the author's purpose in each paragraph. Once you've done that, take a moment to consider how the paragraphs add up. Ask yourself: what was the author's goal in writing this passage
as a whole?
In some cases, the primary purpose might be referenced in each paragraph, as you suggest, but we definitely don't want to assume that's the case. Sometimes, the first paragraph might describe the primary purpose, while the last paragraph is just an afterthought. Other times, the first paragraph may present background info, while a later paragraph states the author's purpose. Whatever the case, it's best to avoid assumptions, and to consider the author's purpose with an open mind.
Let's now apply this strategy to the passage:
- Purpose of Paragraph 1: To explain how the "brain contributes to the adaptive success of animals" by allowing our movements to serve a purpose (such as running away from something).
- Purpose of Paragraph 2: To argue that genes control not only our "brains, muscles, and sensory organs," but our sense of "purpose and complex consciousness."
What do these paragraph's add up to? Well, the second paragraph presents an argument about genetic control. More specifically, it argues that genes control not only our brains (which control our muscles), but our "sense of purpose." How does the first paragraph relate to this? Well, it provides background information to set up the argument in the second paragraph. In other words, it discusses the brain's relationship to basic movements and purpose to provide context for the argument about genetic control of different brain functions.
Let's now consider (A):
Quote:
2) The primary purpose of the passage is to
A) argue that genes may control complex as well as basic brain functions
It's true the first paragraph doesn't mention genes, but that isn't necessarily a problem. Considering the passage as a whole, we see the function of the first paragraph is to provide context for the argument in the second paragraph. So the author's primary purpose is really just to argue that genes control not only our "brains, muscles, and sensory organs," but our sense of "purpose and complex consciousness." This lines up well with answer choice (A), so it's correct.
I hope that helps!